Feasibility-Led Design:
Are We Killing Projects One Decision at a Time?

By Steve Cassells

Director, Neuron · 4 min read

The global housing crisis is often discussed through the lens of planning reform, labour shortages, rising construction costs and government policy. While all these factors play an important role, there is another issue hiding in plain sight that receives far less attention: too many projects become unviable long before anyone realises it.

Too many key design decisions are still made before their full commercial and engineering consequences are understood, quietly reducing saleable area, increasing build cost or diminishing value.

We believe addressing this requires a shift towards Feasibility-Led Design: bringing design, engineering and commercial feasibility together from the outset around one fundamental commercial equation: buy the land, build the building, sell or rent it, and achieve the margin required to make the project viable.

Feasibility then becomes an active design input, continuously testing the decisions that shape cost, yield, value and programme while there is still time to influence them.

A Global Viability Problem

Across Neuron's work in Australia, the UK and the US, we are seeing the same underlying challenge, projects under increasing pressure to balance design ambition, affordability and commercial viability.

The result is that vast numbers of apartments are being designed, approved and documented, only to be found financially unviable once a builder's price is received.

To explore why otherwise promising housing projects are becoming unviable, Neuron recently convened a roundtable with Nick Madgwick (Metis), Michael Clark (Abadeen), Helen Kuo (FK), and Neil Warner O'Connell and David Ritch (Lateral Consulting), professionals who have collectively delivered some of Australia's largest residential developments for organisations including Meriton, Mirvac and Lendlease.

The discussion helped crystallise this thinking around the need for a more feasibility-led approach to design.

The housing crisis is, at least in part, a consequence of failed project feasibility.

As Nick Madgwick of Metis put it:

“Projects don't fail because of one thing. They fail because hundreds of decisions gradually erode viability until the project no longer stacks up.”

– Nick Madgwick, Metis

Why Housing Isn't Getting Built

The challenge is that residential projects must achieve a minimum level of profitability to secure funding and attract investment. In many markets, projects require margins of at least 18% or more before lenders and investors are prepared to proceed.

Every additional design requirement, planning condition, engineering complexity or programme delay increases the total cost of delivery, but the required margin remains unchanged. Those costs must therefore be recovered through higher apartment prices or project viability starts to diminish.

Where the market cannot support the higher purchase prices required, projects simply stop proceeding.

This is one of the less visible drivers of both housing affordability challenges and housing supply shortages globally. As costs continue to rise, but people's lending capacity remains fixed, more projects are reaching a tipping point where additional requirements can no longer be absorbed.

Nick Madgwick of Metis explained that developers also have to think about the long game. They are not simply trying to make individual projects work, but to build long-term businesses capable of surviving decades of economic cycles, construction risk and regulatory change.

“It's not necessarily about the first project shooting the lights out. It's about the success of the tenth and twelfth projects down the line.”

– Nick Madgwick, Metis

These margins are therefore not only a lending requirement, but part of maintaining a viable business over the long term.

The Hidden Cost of Design Decisions

Michael Clark from Abadeen highlighted a residential project where the decision to locate parking underground rather than above ground added approximately $6 million in direct construction costs on a 100-apartment development.

However, the true cost, he argued, is what happens afterwards. The excavation added six months to the programme, significantly increasing finance costs.

"At the back end of that project, that's roughly $500,000 a month in interest. By the time you divide that across 100 apartments, buyers are effectively paying another $25,000 each purely in bank interest so they can have underground parking. And then every one of those costs gets taxed, margined and compounded all the way through the process."

— Michael Clark, Abadeen

Once the additional financing, holding and other flow-on costs of that delay were factored in, Michael estimated the total impact of that single decision at close to $100,000 per apartment, illustrating the kind of cost escalation associated with certain design decisions.

A change in parking rates, additional basement levels, higher infrastructure contributions, or inefficient building forms required to achieve planning approval may each seem reasonable in isolation. Collectively, however, because project viability margins are largely fixed, every additional cost must ultimately be absorbed somewhere: either passed through to the purchaser or absorbed by the project, diminishing its viability.

What is Feasibility-Led Design?

Every development is governed by three numbers:

icon

Land cost

icon

Construction cost

icon

Sale or rental revenue

If revenue exceeds the cost of land and construction by enough to justify the risk, the project gets built. If it doesn't, it gets shelved.

While economic conditions largely determine what buyers or tenants can afford to pay, and land is often already acquired, the cost of construction is the main lever we have to influence project viability. As David Ritch of Lateral Consulting noted, “the single greatest influence on that cost is the design itself.”

Building form, structural design, MEP servicing, amenity, planning outcomes and programme duration all influence cost, yield and ultimately project viability.

Feasibility-Led Design makes viability an active design input. It brings design, engineering and commercial feasibility together from the earliest stages of a project, continuously testing the decisions that affect cost, yield, value and programme while there is still time to influence them.

Rather than allowing key design decisions to become fixed before their engineering and commercial consequences are fully understood, project teams can make better-informed decisions about where to spend, where to optimise and where to protect value.

For developers, this means greater visibility over the decisions that affect viability, fewer late surprises and better-informed commercial choices. For architects, it means understanding constraints earlier, when there is still flexibility to respond creatively and protect the design vision through delivery.

As discussed with Helen Kuo of FK during the roundtable, the thinking behind Feasibility-Led Design starts with:

"understanding what a project needs to cost to build in order to remain both viable and affordable. The evolving design is then continually tested against that target, helping guide the hundreds of decisions that shape the final outcome.”

— Helen Kuo, FK

Why the Traditional Sequence Needs to Change

Historically, housing developments have followed a relatively linear process. A vision is established, designers create a concept, consultants refine the solution, and feasibility is periodically reviewed. If costs exceed expectations, teams enter a value-engineering phase to recover viability.

This process can work when project margins are strong. But in the current market, where margins are increasingly difficult to achieve, it becomes far less forgiving. By the time detailed engineering begins, many of the decisions with the greatest impact on feasibility have already been made and locked in, making changes difficult and expensive. At the same time, construction costs remain high, finance costs are elevated, and approval pathways continue to lengthen.

As a result, many industry leaders are questioning whether the traditional sequence should be reversed. Rather than beginning with an aspirational design and testing feasibility later, projects should start by understanding affordability, market demand and commercial constraints from day one.

This mirrors the approach used in many other industries. Car manufacturers begin with a target customer and price point, then create and evaluate a design to meet that brief.

As Cassells explains, designing without seeing the feasibility impacts is like driving in a new area with a sat nav that only provides directions once every thirty minutes. By the time you're told you've missed a turn, you're already way off course, and the effort required to get back on track is far greater, if at all.

The Future of Housing Delivery

No single stakeholder can solve the housing crisis alone. Developers, architects, engineers, planners, councils, governments, financiers and builders all influence project feasibility. Every planning condition, design decision, engineering solution and programme extension affects whether a project proceeds and whether housing remains affordable.

The challenge is not affordability versus design excellence. The challenge is finding the best balance of the two. That point is different for every site, market and city. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, but there is a repeatable methodology. By making feasibility an input to design, project teams can identify the optimum balance between quality, cost and deliverability, creating better buildings that are more likely to get built.

The opportunity now is for the industry to change how projects begin. Bringing design, engineering and commercial feasibility together earlier gives teams more information while the greatest range of options is still available. Feasibility-Led Design is not about allowing cost to dictate design. It is about giving great design a stronger chance of remaining viable and ultimately being built.

With AI making technology faster and cheaper to create, tools and solutions that once seemed difficult to build are now increasingly achievable. What we need first is a clear framework, so the industry can align around the problem, identify the gaps and begin building the solutions together.

“Beautiful buildings that never get built ultimately fail their purpose. The best building isn't the one that looks best in a render. It's the one that actually gets built.”

— Neil Warner O’Connell, Lateral Consulting

Watch the full roundtable discussion

Hear the full 45-minute conversation that helped shape the thinking behind Feasibility-Led Design.